The Utah Backcountry Discovery Route travels almost 900 miles through some of the state’s most scenic and remote landscapes utilizing a patchwork of dirt roads, 4×4 trails and a few short stretches of blacktop. It begins in Monument Valley, winds through Cedar Mesa, then passes over the Abajo and La Sal Mountains before heading north through the San Rafael Swell, into the Wasatch and eventually ending at Bear Lake on the Idaho/Utah border. It was developed and originally ridden by a group of adventure motorcyclists although the entire route can also be driven in a well-equipped four wheel drive.
I originally planned to ride it in September with a good friend from Colorado but those plans fell through. Rather than let the route antagonize me for another year I made a last minute decision to ride it solo. I had four days to plan the ride, get all my gear together, download GPS tracks and prep my bike – all while maintaining my regular work schedule. I’d have six days to do the ride, which eventually became five when I was unable to leave on time due to my persistent inability to finish packing in time.
I headed south out of Moab on Saturday, August 5, arriving in Monument Valley two hours later. I gassed up, ate a cheap plate of tacos at Goulding’s and turned around to begin my adventure on the Utah BDR. Mexican Hat came and went, and I soon found myself turning on to the first leg of dirt road at Valley of the Gods. I haven’t ridden much this year and my dirt skills were less ninja, more sumo. Luckily, it’s nearly as smooth as unkempt tarmac – perfect for building confidence. Valley of the Gods is much like a miniature version of Monument Valley, but without all the regulations governing where you can and can’t go, what you can and can’t do and where you can and can’t camp. Near the end of the dirt road I caught up with Rick and Norm, who were riding big BMW GS’s. Even before we stopped to chat, I knew we were BDR brothers. After a quick chat, we agreed to ride on together.
Back on asphalt we headed north, climbing up onto Cedar Mesa via the unpaved Moki Dugway. A short distance later we began tackling the first challenging terrain on Snow Flat Road. A storm was brewing on the northern horizon, punctuated by flashes of lightning and the distant rumble of thunder. Immediately upon turning off the pavement we found ourselves riding through a fine, powdery sand just deep enough to cause our bikes to wiggle around in a perpetual battle for balance. Multiple signs issued ominous warnings of “Road is impassable when wet” – not exactly what I wanted to read with a thunderstorm bearing down on us. The road alternated between long stretches of silt broken by short stretches of bumpy slickrock and, here and there, small patches of mud. Not just any mud, mind you – clay mud. Slicker than ice and stickier than sap, it’s a motorcyclist’s nightmare. Rick and Norm had already gone down a few times in the sand. The mud claimed another victim. We rode on, dropping off small slickrock ledges, one of which ripped off the kickstand kill switch on my bike. Rick went down again and after we got his bike upright, he and Norm told me to continue on without them as they didn’t want to hold me up. I debated whether I should leave them but with an impending storm and several miles of clay, sand and rock ahead of us, I decided to carry on by myself.
The official route leaves Snow Flat Road and travels north on Butler Wash Road. Remember that word: wash. I rode into Bluff for a cold drink and to check the weather report. While enjoying a cup of chocolate ice cream at the delightful Comb Ridge Coffee shop, I consulted The Weather Channel on my iPhone. Weather advisory: torrential rain of up to 1″ per hour north of Bluff with flood advisories in effect until 4:00 PM. Not wanting to be swept away in a flash flood, at worst, or ride for hours in clay mud, at best, I decided to detour around Butler Wash and pick up the next leg of the route off Hwy. 95 west of Blanding.
Having ridden all day in the heat of the desert I was excited for this next stretch as it travels over the Abajo Mountains through a cool and shady forest of pine and aspen trees. The road is generally easy riding, alternating between hard pack with a few stretches of smooth, fast slickrock. I passed several idyllic campsites nestled in the trees as I was intent on pushing onward. I wanted to get as many miles as possible under my knobbies on the first day so I wouldn’t be quite so rushed on the remainder of the trip. This turned out to be a bad decision.
I’d been riding for 11 hours and over 300 miles when I encountered the first stretch of sand. I remember thinking, “Are you kidding? Why is their friggin’ sand in the mountains?!” I made it several miles through the stuff, which was deeper and more difficult than anything I’d already ridden down in the desert. And then, on a curve, the inevitable happened – I ran out of luck, skill and speed. The bike came to a stop, I tried to put my foot down and found nothing but air. The bike tipped over in slow motion as I hopped off to avoid being caught beneath it. I took a couple photos of the Tiger taking a nap, then set about trying to pick it up. At about this time I felt a burning sensation on my side, opened my jacket and found a bee shoving his stinger into my skin.
One of the unwritten rules of adventure riding is that you will drop your bike. When you do, you should be able to pick it up. On your own. I’ve dropped it before and I’ve been able to pick it up before. This time, the cards were stacked against me. The bike was on a slight decline, which is a worst case scenario because it requires you to work even more against gravity. And, I was in sand, trying to pick up a 550 pound bike, with nothing firm underfoot for the soles of my riding boots to grip. Every time I’d get the bike halfway up my feet would slip and it would fall back down again. This hell started at 7:00 PM. At around 8:00, I was exhausted and was planning on spending the night in the middle of a lonely dirt road. About 15 minutes later a truckload of hunters rolled up. They jumped out, all decked out in camouflage, and strolled over to give me a hand. After we righted the bike they pointed out a set of large bear tracks in the sand that passed right by the spot where I’d crashed. At least I’d have had some company had I spent the night there, right?
Off I rode, until just around the next curve I ran into more deep sand. I was tapped. Physically and mentally, I was shot. My front tire washed out in the sand and again, the bike and I toppled over. The hunters again stopped, helped me pick up the bike, and very kindly offered to follow me into Blanding. I hadn’t planned on detouring into Blanding but it seemed like the only logical option. Off we went into the night, me on my bike and the hunters trailing behind in their pickup truck. I still had 20 miles to go but luckily, the road turned to hard pack almost immediately and then, 15 miles later, to pavement. I was riding well below the speed limit when a deer darted across the road and came to a stop directly in front of me. Ever heard the term “deer in the headlights”? She was transfixed by mine and clearly wasn’t budging. I grabbed a big handful of brakes and let the ABS do it’s thing. As the distance between me and the deer quickly closed I braced for the impact. Then, at the very last millisecond, the deer leapt out of the way. If I’d had my wits about me I literally could have reached out and smacked her in the ass as I went past.
I stopped at the first hotel I saw in Blanding: the Four Winds Inn. Fifty bucks a night and vacancy. Sold. I collapsed on the bed and quickly passed out after a hasty dinner of beef jerky and trail mix. On Sunday, I made the difficult decision to cancel the rest of the trip. I was sore, my confidence was lacking and I didn’t feel safe riding the remainder of the route alone, much less in only four days. After a huge plate of huevos rancheros I headed north, riding a short section of dirt road off Highway 191 and then over the La Sal Mountains on the Geyser Pass Road before dropping into Moab.
Making the decision to abandon the remainder of the Utah Backcountry Discovery Route was tough. Really tough. I rarely make the decision to quit in the face of adversity but this time, for whatever reason, I just didn’t feel like karma was on my side. The route will be there next year, and so will I.
- Dirt road through Valley of the Gods
- Impending storm over Snow Flat Road on Cedar Mesa
- Delicious chocolate ice cream at Comb Ridge Coffee shop in Bluff, Utah
- A Tiger takes a nap in the Abajo Mountains
- Random ranch road north of the Needles with La Sal Mountains in background
- In the pines near the top of Geyser Pass in the La Sal Mountains















23 Responses to “Adventure and Disappointment on the Utah Backcountry Discovery Route”
Jeff Colburn says:
At least you’re okay. If you went through what you did, and your gut tells you to stop, you should. Who knows what was waiting down the road for you. Like you said, the road will be there next year.
Have Fun,
Jeff
Alister Benn says:
Wow… they always say the toughest adventures make the best stories, and this is very much the case here…. Congrats on a safe return.
Greg Russell says:
Sorry to hear your trip was cut short, Bret, but this still looks like an amazing trip. That’s some rugged country you passed through, and this was good beta for next year’s trip…
Bret Edge says:
Thanks, Greg. It will be an amazing trip. The scenery is certainly tough to beat. It’s really not all that technical of a ride but for some reason, I just was not feeling confident. I’ve never had such a weird, nagging feeling before and I felt I’d better listen to my gut.
Bret Edge says:
Thank you, Alister. It definitely makes for an interesting story although I’d rather still be on the ride!
Bret Edge says:
Really appreciate the comment, Jeff. I’m not one who often listens to instinct but I think I made the right choice this time around.
Bill Bean says:
Awww Man….I’m sorry it didn’t work out the way you planned. The good news is the Tiger didn’t go down with you pinned under it. Just a thought: If you go next year, maybe have someone follow along in a 4X4 support vehicle? I’m not familiar with the specifics of the BDR but it might be a wise decision.
Bret Edge says:
I have considered that Bill but it feels a bit like cheating to me. I know, I’m messed up. I kind of like to do these things the silly way. To badly paraphrase a wise man, “I may not be a smart man, but I know what adventure is.”
Eric says:
Bret, even though I’m sure you are disappointed at least you made the effort and are safe at home now. When the time is right you can try again and next time I am sure you will be successful!
Eric
G Dan Mitchell says:
Wow, Bret – great story, though perhaps not quite in the ways you intended!
Dan
Jackson Frishman says:
I’ve definitely had some times when I turned back from a planned adventure because luck just wasn’t on my side. It’s always a tough decision, but even setting aside safety, sometimes it just stops being fun and you realize you’d rather spend your time not being stressed for several days.
I’ve also weathered a couple cloudbursts on Cedar Mesa, and they are not kidding about Impassable When Wet out there.
Great story in any case!
Scott Bacon says:
Wow, epic day!! And a crazy close call with the deer. Yikes!
Sorry I couldn’t be there to help get “el Tigre” back upright. Although I’m sure you would have spent MORE time helping me get my GS off the ground.
Sounds like the road conditions were interesting. Sand = blech! Count this as a scouting trip for next year!! And we can add the CO BDR to our bucket list.
Kevin La Rue says:
Wow – great story, despite the disappointment of being turned back. Dude – you made the right decision. When it doesn’t feel right, ya gotta trust your [well-honed] instincts.
The earlier comment about this being a “beta test” was spot on.
Samantha says:
Brave Bret, I so admire your adventurous nature, and you relate a great story. I’m glad you realized that this was not the time. I trust that you will mull over what you learned and it will help you be successful when next you set out. Me? I’d have turned back when it looked like my hair might get wet. Blessings to you and your family.
Bret Edge says:
Yeah, I’m not a big fan of sand but we’re gonna have to deal with it in Utah and Arizona. I just need to get out and ride it more often so I’ve got the skills and confidence to go fast and power through it. I will gladly help you pick up the big GS! In a weird way, I’m kinda glad I bagged on the Utah BDR so we can do it together next year. That kinda thing is definitely more fun with friends!
Bret Edge says:
I’ve driven and ridden on wet clay before and it is NO fun. Hateful, actually. You bring up a really good point that I failed to mention in my post, Jackson. I’m usually super psyched about trips like this but for some reason, I wasn’t this time around. I just assumed it was stress and that my attitude would change once I hit the road. Unfortunately, it never really did. I enjoyed it, mostly, but I just kept thinking that I’d rather be at home with my family. It definitely wasn’t the right time to do this trip and I sort of feel like someone was giving me a few hints along the way that I’d probably better just call it quits. Who knows though, right?
Ron Niebrugge says:
O man, that is a bummer – but it did make for an interesting blog post.
Bret Edge says:
Glad you enjoyed it, Ron.
Bret Edge says:
Thank you for the comment and support, Samantha. Much appreciated! Hope we get to see you some time in the near future.
Bret Edge says:
Yeah, it definitely didn’t end up the way I wanted it to but if every adventure went as planned, they wouldn’t really be adventures, would they?
Bret Edge says:
Eric: I’ll definitely re-group and go back next year to try again. They just finished the Colorado Backcountry Discovery Route, and it’s next on the agenda after Utah.
Derek (100 Peaks) says:
Good call. Your instincts were likely right. Bailing out can be hard, but if your guts tells you it’s the right thing to do, then you are definitely a wise person. Good luck on your next adventure.
Bret Edge says:
Thanks, Derek. Every once in a while I do the right thing and listen to my instincts. I think it was the right call this time around.